Rollout of New WalMart Brand All Backwards

When the new WalMart logo appeared a few weeks ago, many of us speculated as to its intended meaning. What was that starburst all about? My belief is that it has to do with repositioning the WalMart brand against competitors such as Target, who allow WalMart to hold the low-end price leader position. But it’s a guess, because WalMart’s brand management has been so confusing.

The only thing stranger than the new corporate identity is the rollout itslef. I went visiting WalMart stores and saw no sign of the new logo. The old WalMart logo, with the star, was on the front signs, the shopping bags, the name tages, everywhere I looked - except on the bottom of the WalMart TV news screen. There the new starburst logo sat by itself. The familiar yellow smiley faces still filled the store, touting WalMart as the low-price leader. But the new logo was noticeably absent.

The rollout of the logo shows a brand identity program that is completely backwards. Let’s think about it. About 8 months ago, WalMart announced it would be selling organic produce. Aha! Something to entice the more upscale customer. But could they believe WalMart as a trusted provider of organic products? Hmm.

Then we got the new tagline on the radio and TV ads: “Save money. Live better.” So, now it’s not just about looking for the lowest price, but to live a richer life because I can spend my saved money on things that matter (hopefully on the organic produce). Months after that comes the new starburst logo, with no explanation. And dripped out ever so slowly. Have you seen the ads that have the old bags and the new logo? I can hear the discussion in the WalMart conference room. “Why waste money re-doing old footage when we can just edit the old ads and the new logo together?”

Yes, implementing a new logo costs money. If anyone understands supply chain costs, it’s WalMart.  But that is no excuse for getting the order of the brand identity all wrong. First we should have seen the new logo with a big messaging splash about how you can not only save money, but live the better life. Then, with that positioning firmly planted in our minds, should have come the proof points, such as the availability of organic produce.

This so-called campaign is a muddled mess. Yes, they saved some implementation costs. But they lost the brand message. Maybe their new tag line should be “Save money. Muddle brand.”

Popularity: 87% [?]